My score: 206

A total waste of time, but still interesting:
Basically, put an asterisk by each movie you've seen and then add 5 movies on to the end.

1. Napoleon Dynamite
2. Saw
3. White Noise
4. White Oleander
5. Anger Management*
6. 50 First Dates*
7. Friday The 13th*
8. Scream*
9. Scream 2*
10. Scream 3*
11. Scary Movie*
12. Scary Movie 2*
13. Scary Movie 3*
14. American Pie*
15. American Pie 2*
16. American Wedding*
17. Harry Potter and the Philosopher's (Sorcerer's) Stone*
18. Harry Potter and the Chamber of Secrets*
19. Harry Potter and the Prisoner of Azkaban*
20. Resident Evil*
21. Resident Evil: Apocalypse*
22. The Wedding Singer*
23. Little Black Book
24. The Village
25. Donnie Darko
26. Lilo & Stitch*
27. Finding Nemo*
28. Finding Neverland
29. 13 Ghosts*
30. Signs*
31. The Grinch*
32. The Texas Chainsaw Massacre (the original)
33. White Chicks
34. The Butterfly Effect
35. 13 going on 30
36. I, Robot
37. Dodgeball
38. Universal Soldier
39. A Series Of Unfortunate Events
40. Along Came A Spider
41. Deep Impact*
42. Kingpin
43. Never Been Kissed*
44. Meet The Parents*
45. Meet The Fockers
46. Eight Crazy Nights*
47. A Cinderella Story
48. The Terminal
49. The Lizzie McGuire Movie
50. Passport to Paris
51. Dumb & Dumber*
52. Dumb & Dumberer*
53. Final Destination
54. Final Destination 2*
55. Halloween*
56. Halloween 2
57. Halloween 3
58. Halloween 4
59. Halloween 5
60. H20
61. Halloween: the Resurrection
62. The Ring
63. The Ring 2
64. Harold & Kumar Go to White Castle
65. Practical Magic*
66. Chicago*
67. Ghost Ship
68. From Hell
69. Team America: World Police*
70. Hellboy
71. Secret Window*
72. I Am Sam
73. The Whole Nine Yards*
74. The Day After Tomorrow8
75. Child's Play*
76. Bride of Chucky
77. 10 Things I Hate About You*
78. Just Married
79. Gothika
80. A Nightmare on Elm Street*
81. Sixteen Candles*
82. Bad Boys 2 (what happened to Bad Boys 1??)*
83. Joy Ride
84. Seven*
85. Ocean's Eleven*
86. Ocean's Twelve
87. Identity
88. Lone Star
89. Bedazzled*
90. Predator
91. Predator II
92. Independence Day*
93. Cujo
94. A Bronx Tale
95. Darkness Falls
96. Christine*
97. ET*
98. Children of the Corn
99. My Boss' Daughter
100. Maid in Manhattan*
101. Frailty
102. How to Lose a Guy in 10 Days*
103. She's All That*
104. Calendar Girls
105. Sideways
106. Mars Attacks*
107. Event Horizon
108. Ever After*
109. Forrest Gump*
110. Big Trouble in Little China*
111. X-Men*
112. X-Men 2*
113. Jeepers Creepers
114. Jeepers Creepers 2
115. Catch Me If You Can*
116. The Others
117. Freaky Friday (the original)*
118. Reign of Fire
119. Man on Fire
120. Braveheart*
121. Cruel Intentions*
122. The Hot Chick
123. Swimfan
124. Miracle
125. Friday Night Lights
126. Old School
127. Ray
128. The Notebook*
129. K-Pax
130. Lord of the Rings: The Fellowship of the Ring*
131. Lord of the Rings: The Two Towers*
132. Lord of the Rings: The Return of the King*
133. A Walk to Remember
134. Sweet Home Alabama*
135. Moulin Rouge
136. Boogeyman
137. Hitch
138. The Fifth Element*
139. Star Wars episode I: The Phantom Menance*
140. Star Wars episode II: Attack Of The Clones*
141. Star Wars Episode III: Revenge Of The Sith
142. Star Wars episode IV: A New Hope*
143. Star Wars episode V: The Empire Strikes Back*
144. Star Wars episode VI: Return Of The Jedi*
145. Swimming with Sharks
146. Trainspotting
147. People Under the Stairs
148. Blue Velvet
149. The Sound of Music*
150. Parent Trap (the original)*
151. The Burbs*
152. SLC Punk
153. Meet Joe Black*
154. Wild Things*
155. A Clockwork Orange
156. The Order
157. Spider-Man*
158. Spider-Man 2 (in the middle of watching it)
159. Amelie
160. Mean Girls
161. Confessions of a Teenage Drama Queen
162. Shrek*
163. Shrek 2*
164. The Incredibles*
165. Collateral
166. The Fast & The Furious
167. 2 Fast 2 Furious
168. Sky Captain & The World of Tomorrow
169. Closer
170. The Sixth Sense*
171. A.I. - Artificial Intelligence*
172. Love Actually
173. The Sweetest Thing
174. Shutter
175. Ella Enchanted
176. The Princess Diaries*
177. The Princess Diaries 2: Royal Engagement*
178. The Breakfast Club*
179. October Sky
180. Remember the Titans*
181. Titanic*
182. Boondock Saints
183. American History X
184. Fight Club
185. Heavenly Creatures
186. Stealing Beauty
187. Like Water For Chocolate
188. Powwow Highway
189. Secretary
190. But I'm A Cheerleader
191. I <3 Huckabees
192. Ripley's Game
193. Coffee And Cigarettes
194. Taxi Driver
195. Silence Of The Lambs*
196. The Exorcist*
197. If Lucy Fell
198. Lady Jane* (one of my favorites!!!)
199. When Harry Met Sally*
200. Me, Myself & Irene*
201. Kung Fu Hustle
202. Sin City
203. Labyrinth*
204. Much Ado About Nothing*
205. The Cowboy Way
206. Paulie
207. Blazing Saddles
208. Galaxy Quest*
209. Guildenstern & Rosencrantz are Dead
210. Citizen Kane*
211. You Can Count on Me
212. Young Frankenstein
213. Raiders of the Lost Ark*
214. Starman*
215. St. Elmos Fire
216. Coyote Ugly*
217. The Other Sister*
218. Rainman*
219. Little Shop of Horrors*
220. Chasing Amy*
221. House of Sand and Fog
222. Mildred Pierce
223. The Big Lebowski*
224. Mallrats*
225. Eternal Sunshine Of The Spotless Mind
226. The Goonies*
227. Starsky & Hutch*
228. Saved!
229. The Upside of Anger
230. Sweet Sweetback's Baadasssss Song
231. The Cat's Meow
232. The Rutles
233. Waking Ned Devine
234. Pirates of the Caribbean*
235. Little Women
236. Huck Finn*
237. National Treasure
238. O Brother Where Art Thou?*
239. Dick
240. Howard the Duck*
241. Garden State
242. Hero
243. This Is Spinal Tap
244. Almost Famous*
245. Before Sunrise
246. Before Sunset
247. Troy
248. Gone With The Wind*
249. Chocolat*
250. Gentlemen Prefer Blondes*
251. Now and Then*
252. Romeo and Juliet*
253. Ferris Bueller's Day Off*
254. Grease*
255. Guess Who's Coming to Dinner?
256. Mr. North
257. The African Queen
258. The Wizard of Oz*
259. Country Girl
260. The Philadelphia Story
261. Bringing Up Baby
262. The Aviator
263. An Affair To Remember
264. Sabrina*
265. Roman Holiday
266. Conspiracy Theory*
267. Stage Door
268. Rigoletto
269. White Christmas*
270. Who Framed Roger Rabbit?*
271. The Wedding Planner*
272. Arsenic and Old Lace*
273. A Day at the Races
274. Willy Wonka & The Chocolate Factory*
275. Bend it Like Beckham*
276. Troop Beverly Hills*
277. A Beautiful Mind
278. Urban Legend*
279. Dead Poet's Society*
280. Kill Bill vol. 1*
281. Kill Bill vol. 2*
282. The Royal Tenenbaums
283. The Life Aquatic with Steve Zissou
284. American Beauty*
285. A Chorus Line
286. Iron Jawed Angels
287. Phantom of the Opera
288. A League of Their Own*
289. Stuart Little*
290. Notting Hill*
291. A Lot Like Love
292. Along Came Polly
293. Billy Madison*
294. Happy Gilmore*
295. Igby Goes Down
296. Sid and Nancy
297. Bruce Almighty*
298. The Usual Suspects
299. Chances Are
300. SWAT
301. House of Wax (the original w/Vincent Price, thank you very much)
302. Master and Commander: The Far Side of the World*
303. Gladiator*
304. Gosford Park*
305. The Jacket
306. Red Dragon
307. Hannibal*
308. Elizabeth*
309. Quills
310. Velvet Goldmine
311. Chuck and Buck
312. Titus
313. The Pillow Book
314. Queen Margot (thank you madame)
315. Sex, Lies and Videotape
316. His Girl Friday
317. Persuasion
318. Party Girl
319. Top Hat
320. Singing in the Rain*
321. Spirited Away*
322. House of Flying Daggers
323. Goodbye Lenin
324. Willow*
325. Battle Royale
326. Dude, Where's My Car?*
327. Drop Dead Gorgeous
328. Josie and the Pussycats
329. Romancing the Stone*
330. Mystery Men*
331. Bound
332. Crossroads (The Ralph Macchio one, not the Britney Spears one)
333. Dawn Of The Dead (the original)
334. Shaun Of The Dead
335. The Hitchhiker's Guide To The Galaxy*
336. Angels with Dirty Faces
337. Deathrace 2000
338. The Terminator*
339. Unforgiven (1992)*
340. Virtuousity
341. A Life Less Ordinary
342. The Crying Game
343. A Company of Wolves
344. Brotherhood of the Wolf
345. Dirty Work
346. Chutney Popcorn
347. Love in the Time of Money
348. The Life of David Gale
349. Wimbledon
350. Divine Secrets of the YaYa Sisterhood*
351. Stuart Little 2*
352. Rocky Horror Picture Show*
353. Buffy the Vampire Slayer*
354. Star Trek: Nemesis
355. Flight of the Phoenix
356. The Mask of Zorro*
357. Selena*
358. Godsend
359. Enough
360. Murder By Numbers
361. Cube
362. Thought Crimes
363. Van Helsing*
364. The One and Only
365. Uptown Girls
366. Requiem for a Dream
367. Kontroll
368. Kinsey
369. Touching the Void
370. Whale Rider
371. Shark Tale*
372. Stargate*
373. Black Hawk Down
374. Madagascar
375. Finding Forrester
376. Shakespeare in Love*
377. Get Over It
378. Mary Poppins*
379. Indiana Jones & The Last Crusade*
380. Indiana Jones & the Temple of Doom*
381. Daredevil*
382. Green Mile*
383. 8 Mile
384. Clerks*
385. The Thomas Crown Affair (1998)*
386. The King and I (original -- the Yul Brenner version)*
387. Striptease*
388. The Void
389. One Special Night
390. Victor/Victoria
391. The Bridges of Madison County
392. Something's Gotta Give
393. Murder by Death
394. Marnie
395. One, Two, Three
396. Stage Door Canteen
397. Sister Kenney
398. Mame
399. One Flew Over the Cuckoo's Nest
400. Star Trek: The Motion Picture
401. The Pirates of Penzance
402. Movie Movie
403. Circle of Iron
404. Kentucky Fried Movie
405. The Mask (Jim Carrey)*
406. The Shawshank Redemption*
407. Minority Report*
408. The Graduate
409. Shock Treatment*
410. Phantom of the Paradise
411. Taxi
412. Benny & Joon*
413. Brain Candy
414. The Wrong Guy
415. Fried Green Tomatoes*
416. Monty Python and the Holy Grail*
417. Girl, Interrupted*
418. Ghostbusters*
419. That Darn Cat (the original)
420. Moonstruck
421. Bubba Ho-Tep
422. Gigantic: A Tale of Two Johns
423. Can't Hardly Wait*
424. Punch-Drunk Love
425. Office Space*
426: Pee-wee's Big Adventure*
427: Sleepy Hollow*
428: Ed Wood
429: Big Fish
430. Sleepers*
431. The Princess Bride*
432. Being John Malkovich
433. Hedwig and the Angry Inch
434. A Mighty Wind
435. The Muppet Movie*
436. Rocky
437. Wet Hot American Summer
438. Showdown in Little Tokyo
439. American Ninja
440. Ready 2 Rumble
441. Field of Dreams*
442. Fever Pitch
443. For the Love of the Game
444. Eight Men Out*
445. The Natural*
446. The Sting*
447. Lock, Stock, and Two Smoking Barrels
448. Kung Pow: Enter the Fist
449. U571*
450. The Hunt for Red October*
455. American President*
456. Rounders
457. Bridget Jones' Diary*
458. Jerry Maguire*
459. Lost in Translation
460. The Adventures of Buckaroo Bonzai and the 8th Dimension
461. Ninth Gate
462. Rosemary's Baby
463. Dave
464. The Meaning of Life
465. Garden State
466. North (Elijah Wood)
467. The Rules of Attraction
468. Magnolia
469. Rushmore
470. STEEL MAGNOLIAS*
471. DOGMA*
472. JAY AND SILENT BOB STRIKE BACK*
473. THE BANGER SISTERS
474. JERSEY GIRL
475. The Smokers
476. In America
477. The Dangerous Lives of Altar Boys
478. Life as a House
479. Party Monster
480. Anti-Trust*
481. Army of Darkness*
482. Merlin*
483. French Kiss*
484. Fahrenheit 9/11*